Thursday, September 10, 2015
Nnamabia: Good Person or Not?
In our discussion of Cell One, one of the big questions was whether Nnamabia was a good person at the beginning of the story or just at the end. I believe the answer is neither. At the beginning of the story we are given examples of how he robs the family, breaks a window in his classroom, sells exam answers to his father's students, and attempts to make his own key to the family car. I think that part of the problem here is that his mother refuses to punish him, but I believe his constant rule-breaking shows he isn't a good person at the beginning of the story. At the end, one major argument for his becoming a good person is referencing his helping the old man and refusal to dramatize his experiences in jail. The former is harder to argue against, but I believe even the worst people can have moments of humanity. As for the latter, I would say he is broken by his experiences in jail and doesn't wish to relive them.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree that Nnamabia is neither a good or bad person, mostly because it is hard to fit people into boxes like that. Nnamabia did bad things, but he still had humanity left in him. Who are we to judge what is good and bad?
ReplyDelete